The Best Alternatives to Beachbody Hydrate: The Science Behind Electrolyte Supplements

Have you heard of Beachbody? It's one of the many multi-level marketing companies (MLMs) out there that sell health and fitness products like “Hydrate." But did you know that MLMs have come under fire for their business practices and ethical concerns?

That's why it's important to choose anti-MLM products that are just as effective without all the baggage. One such product is electrolyte supplements or an oral rehydration solution (ORS), which are essential for proper hydration and can improve exercise performance. But with so many options, knowing which ones to choose can be tough.

That's where the science behind electrolyte supplements comes in. By understanding the different types of electrolytes and how they work with your body's fluid balance, you can make an informed decision and find the best anti-MLM alternatives to Beachbody Hydrate.

What You Need to Know About Electrolytes

We’ve all heard that staying hydrated is important for our overall health. However, did you know that it's not just about drinking enough water - it's also about maintaining an optimal balance of electrolytes in our body? 

Electrolytes are essential minerals that help transmit electrical impulses within our bodies, regulate our fluid levels, and support critical functions such as muscle contractions and nerve signaling.

Electrolytes = Electrical Impulses, get it?

Inadequate hydration and electrolyte imbalance can lead to a host of health problems, ranging from mild symptoms such as fatigue and headaches to more serious conditions like heat stroke and seizures. 

Electrolytes are essential minerals such as sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium. We find them in our blood, urine, and other bodily fluids.

These minerals carry a positive or negative charge. They are responsible for conducting electrical impulses between cells, regulating fluid balance in our bodies, helping muscles contract, and supporting essential body functions such as heart rate, nerve signaling, and more. 

We lose electrolytes in various ways, such as sweating, urination, or diarrhea. When we sweat excessively, we lose water and electrolytes; if we don't replenish them, we may become dehydrated, impairing our physical and mental performance.

Replenishing electrolytes is particularly vital for individuals who engage in intense physical activity, live in hot environments, have medical conditions such as certain gastrointestinal conditions, or are on certain medications (e.g., diuretics).

Furthermore, certain dietary choices may also impact our body's electrolyte balance. Carbohydrates, for example, are essential for hydration as they help the body absorb and retain water. 

For example, if you follow a very low-carbohydrate diet, your body may lose electrolytes more quickly than it can absorb, leading to an imbalance.

This is why many electrolyte supplements contain sugar. The body breaks down sugar into glucose, which helps absorb and retain electrolytes more effectively.

Recommended Intake of Electrolyte Supplements

The optimal electrolyte ratio for an ORS can vary depending on individual needs, fitness goals, activity levels, and specific health conditions. 

Clinical recommendations for electrolyte supplementation may also differ based on the purpose of supplementation (e.g., hydration during workouts, managing medical conditions).

The most common electrolytes found in supplements are sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium. However, there is no universally agreed-upon "best" electrolyte ratio, as individual needs can vary.

For hydration during exercise, a commonly recommended ratio is:

  • Sodium: 500-700 mg per liter of fluid

  • Potassium: 150-300 mg per liter of fluid

  • Calcium: Not typically a primary focus for hydration supplements

  • Magnesium: Not typically a primary focus for hydration supplements

Additionally, as I mentioned, sugar (glucose) is often added to electrolyte supplements to facilitate absorption. 

While overall added sugar intake should be limited, it is important to choose an electrolyte supplement that contains some sugar to support the function of the supplement.

Evaluating Beachbody Hydrate

Hydrate is a product within the Beachbody Performance line by BODi, a well-known multi-level marketing (MLM) company in the health and fitness industry. 

As an MLM, BODi operates through a network of independent distributors who earn commissions by selling products and recruiting new distributors. 

This business model has garnered mixed consumer opinions due to the ethical concerns associated with MLMs.

Overview of Beachbody Hydrate

The ingredient list of Beachbody Hydrate includes organic cane sugar, dextrose, citric acid, silica, natural flavors, stevia leaf extract, and a notable addition of quercetin. Quercetin has been a popular supplement ingredient in the past. 

Still, because there is no scientific evidence that it has any real health benefits, the supplemental use of it is considered outdated.

It's also worth noting that the dosage of the key nutrients for an electrolyte supplement like calcium, magnesium, sodium, and potassium are relatively low compared to clinical recommendations and other available supplements on the market.

When comparing Beachbody Hydrate to the recommended supplemental intakes for electrolytes, it's important to consider the specific nutrient amounts provided in the product and how they align with the recommended daily intakes. 

Based on the information provided on the label, here is a comparison:

  1. Sodium: Each serving of Beachbody Hydrate provides 230 mg of sodium, which falls within the lower range of the recommended intake for adults. Supplemental recommendations suggest a range of 500-700 mg per liter of fluid for hydration during exercise, indicating that Beachbody Hydrate may not provide enough.

  2. Potassium: Beachbody Hydrate contains 80 mg of potassium per serving, representing only around 2% of the recommended intake for adults. Supplemental recommendations suggest a range of 150-300 mg per liter of fluid for hydration during exercise, indicating that Beachbody Hydrate may not provide adequate potassium.

  3. Calcium: Each serving of Beachbody Hydrate provides 10 mg of calcium, less than 1% of the recommended daily intake for adults. Calcium is not typically the primary focus of electrolyte supplements for hydration during exercise, but it is still an important mineral for overall health.

  4. Magnesium: Beachbody Hydrate provides 40 mg of magnesium per serving, representing approximately 10% of the recommended intake for adults. While this amount is relatively low compared to the upper end of the recommended intake range, it can contribute to overall magnesium intake.

It's evident that the electrolyte amounts in Beachbody Hydrate, particularly potassium, calcium, and sodium, are relatively low compared to the recommended daily intakes and clinical recommendations for hydration during exercise. 

Individuals with higher electrolyte needs, such as those engaging in intense or prolonged exercise or with specific health conditions, may require additional supplementation or alternative products with higher electrolyte content.

BODi actually acknowledges this on the package, as the label recommends taking one additional serving every 30 minutes of continuous exercise. 

While this approach allows for some flexibility in adjusting the electrolyte intake based on the workout duration, it also raises questions about the $37 cost of the product. 

Considering the relatively low electrolyte content and it being nearly a dollar per serving, the cost of using multiple servings of Beachbody Hydrate regularly may become an important factor to consider.

Regarding safety and efficacy, Beachbody Hydrate (like most supplements) has not been clinically tested, and its dosing and ingredients are not backed by scientific evidence. 

It is essential to understand any supplement's ingredients and potential health risks before using it and weigh the benefits against the cost. 

Personally, I would pass on Beachbody Hydrate and look for a better value alternative with a higher quality formulation.

Looking for Alternatives to Beachbody Hydrate

If you're looking for alternatives to Beachbody Hydrate, here are a few factors to consider:

  1. Ingredient Profile: When evaluating electrolyte supplements, it's important to consider the presence of sugar. While some sugar is necessary to facilitate electrolyte absorption, excessive sugar intake should be avoided for overall health. Look for a supplement that strikes a balance between providing the necessary sugar for absorption without excessive amounts.

  2. Electrolyte Content: Check the levels of essential electrolytes such as sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium. Look for a supplement that provides adequate electrolytes based on clinical recommendations for hydration during exercise or your specific needs.

  3. Balanced Ratio: Opt for a supplement that offers a balanced ratio of electrolytes. While the specific ratio may vary depending on individual needs and activity levels, a general guideline is to aim for higher sodium and potassium content than calcium and magnesium.

  4. Cost-effectiveness: Compare the prices of similar hydration products to find options that fit your budget without compromising quality. Consider the cost per serving and the overall value provided by the supplement.

  5. Reputation and Safety: Research the brand's reputation and check for third-party certifications to ensure the product's safety and quality. Look for supplements that undergo rigorous testing and adhere to industry standards.

  6. Personal Preferences: Consider factors like taste, flavor options, and convenience of use (e.g., powdered form vs. ready-to-drink) that align with your preferences and lifestyle. Choosing a supplement you enjoy consuming will increase the likelihood of consistent use.

The Best Alternatives to Beachbody Hydrate

Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier

Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier comes in a variety of flavors, including Seaberry, Strawberry Lemonade, Tropical Punch, Pina Colada, Concord Grape, Golden Cherry, Acai Berry, Guava, Lemon Lime, Passion Fruit, Strawberry, and Watermelon.

The nutritional breakdown for one stick (16 grams) of this hydration supplement is as follows:

  • Calories: 45 (11 g Added sugar)

  • Sodium: 500 mg (22% Daily Value, DV)

  • Potassium: 370 mg (8% DV)

  • Vitamin C: 76 mg (80% DV)

Furthermore, Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier provides substantial amounts of B vitamins. It contains 140%, 130%, 230%, and 280% of your daily needs of vitamins B3, B6, B5, and B12, respectively.

When we compare the amounts of key electrolytes provided by Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier to recommended values, we find:

  1. Sodium: Each stick offers 500 mg of sodium, which is comfortably within the recommended range of 500-700 mg per liter of fluid for hydration during exercise. This suggests that Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier provides an adequate amount of sodium.

  2. Potassium: The product contains 370 mg of potassium per stick, representing about 8% of the recommended intake for adults. This exceeds the suggested range of 150-300 mg per liter of fluid for hydration during exercise.

  3. Calcium: Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier doesn't contain calcium, but it's not a main concern for an ORS.

  4. Magnesium: Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier doesn't contain magnesium, but it's not a main concern for an ORS.

Overall, Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier provides higher amounts of sodium and potassium than other products, like Beachbody Hydrate.

They have less of a calcium and magnesium content, but the higher amounts of sodium and potassium make them more effective for hydration.

Adding B vitamins is a nice touch and may help combat workouts or heat-induced muscle fatigue.

At the time of writing, a 16-pack of Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier is available for about $25, making it about $1.56 per serving.

While this is more expensive per serving than Beachbody Hydrate, Liquid I.V. is a better value because to get a similar dosage of sodium, you would need to consume two servings of Beachbody Hydrate - and you still wouldn't come close to the potassium content found in Liquid I.V.

LMNT Electrolytes

LMNT comes in various flavors, including Raw Unflavored, Citrus Salt, Orange Salt, Watermelon Salt, Mango Chili, Lemon Habanero, and Chocolate Salt.

The nutritional breakdown for one packet (to be mixed with 16 to 32 ounces of water) of this hydration supplement is as follows:

  • Calories: 10

  • Sodium: 1000 mg

  • Potassium: 200 mg

  • Magnesium: 60 mg

It's noteworthy that LMNT is sugar-free and sweetened with stevia leaf powder. Without some sugar, the electrolytes could be much less absorbable.

When we compare the amounts of key electrolytes provided by LMNT to recommended values, we find:

  1. Sodium: Each packet offers 1000 mg of sodium, significantly higher than the recommended range of 500-700 mg per liter of fluid for hydration during exercise. This suggests that LMNT provides a substantial amount of sodium, making it potentially more effective for rehydration.

  2. Potassium: The product contains 200 mg of potassium per packet,within the suggested range of 150-300 mg per liter of fluid for hydration during exercise. This meets the criteria for effective rehydration.

  3. Calcium: LMNT doesn't contain calcium, but this isn't a major concern for a supplement intended to replace electrolytes.

  4. Magnesium: Each packet contains 60 mg of magnesium. While not a primary electrolyte for rehydration, supplemental magnesium can contribute to overall electrolyte balance.

LMNT provides higher amounts of sodium than other products, like Beachbody Hydrate and Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier.

The sodium content may be too high for most people, but this could be useful in extreme dehydration or heavy sweat loss.

At the time of writing, a box of 30 packets of LMNT is available for about $45, making it about $1.50 per serving.

This is cheaper than Liquid I.V. but more expensive than Beachbody Hydrate. It is a better value than Beachbody Hydrate regarding efficiency; however, Liquid I.V. is better balanced for people in general use.

DripDrop

DripDrop comes in a few flavors, including Berry, Lemon, and Watermelon.

The nutritional breakdown for one packet (to be mixed with 8 ounces of water) of this hydration supplement is as follows:

  • Calories: 35 (7g of sugar)

  • Sodium: 330 mg

  • Potassium: 185 mg

  • Magnesium: 39 mg

  • Vitamin C: 70mg

  • Zinc: 1.5mg

When we compare the amounts of key electrolytes provided by DripDrop to recommended values, we find:

  1. Sodium: Each packet offers 330 mg of sodium, lower than the recommended range of 500-700 mg per liter of fluid for hydration during exercise. This suggests that DripDrop may not provide sufficient sodium for effective rehydration.

  2. Potassium: The product contains 185 mg of potassium per packet, below the suggested range of 150-300 mg per liter of fluid for hydration during exercise. This suggests that DripDrop may not provide sufficient potassium to rehydrate effectively. 

  3. Calcium: DripDrop doesn't contain calcium, but this isn't necessarily a major concern for an ORS.

  4. Magnesium: Each packet contains 39 mg of magnesium. While not a primary electrolyte for rehydration, supplemental magnesium can contribute to overall electrolyte balance.

Overall, DripDrop provides lower amounts of sodium and potassium than other products, like Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier - but there is more than Beachbody Hydration.

Adding Vitamin C and Zinc is a nice touch and could contribute to better overall muscle recovery from your workouts.

At the time of writing, a box of 16 packets of DripDrop is available for about $19, making it about $1.19 per serving.

This is cheaper than Liquid I.V. but more expensive than Beachbody Hydrate. While DripDrop does provide some additional vitamins and minerals, it may not be as effective for hydration due to the lower sodium and potassium content. 

DripDrop is probably best suited for people who need electrolyte supplementation but still limit their sugar and sodium intake.

Something interesting about DripDrop is that, unlike the other electrolyte powders here, It's "Certified for Sport" by NSF International. This rigorous certification system ensures the product does not contain any banned substances and has been tested for purity, potency, and safety.

Competitive athletes who must adhere to the rules of their sport may find this certification appealing. Furthermore, it also serves as a testament to the product's commitment to quality and safety.

Electrolyte Supplement FAQs

Who needs electrolyte supplements?

Anyone who sweats heavily for extended periods can benefit from electrolyte supplements. 

Because we lose electrolytes in our sweat, people who work outdoors in hot and humid climates, exercise for extended periods, or those with certain medical conditions that cause excessive sweating or dehydration could benefit from a supplement designed to replace the electrolytes lost.

Are electrolyte supplements safe?

When taken as directed, electrolyte supplements are generally considered safe for healthy adults. However, it is important to follow the directions on the product label and speak to your doctor if you have any questions or concerns before taking them. 

People with kidney problems should be especially cautious when taking supplements containing potassium.

When should I take electrolyte supplements?

Generally, electrolyte supplements should be taken before, during, and after your workout or other activities that cause significant sweating. This helps ensure optimal hydration throughout the activity. 

It is also a good idea to drink plenty of water in addition to taking electrolyte supplements.

What are the side effects of electrolyte supplements?

Electrolyte supplements are generally safe when directed, but you should consider the potential side effects. These include gastrointestinal issues like diarrhea and stomach cramps, allergic reactions, electrolyte imbalances leading to symptoms such as muscle weakness or irregular heartbeat, interactions with medications, and risks for individuals with kidney conditions. 

To minimize the risk of side effects, follow recommended dosages, choose reputable brands, and consult a healthcare professional if you have any concerns or underlying health conditions.

What is the difference between electrolyte supplements and sports drinks?

Electrolyte supplements and sports drinks differ in their composition and purpose. Electrolyte supplements, such as ORS, often in powder or tablet form, focus on delivering specific electrolytes like sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium to correct imbalances or boost hydration during intense workouts.

Typical sports drinks are carbohydrate-based, replenish fluid, provide energy, improve endurance, and improve exercise performance. 

Sports drinks usually have lower electrolyte concentrations and may contain higher amounts of added sugars to provide quick digesting energy for muscle glycogen recovery and sustained exercise. 

Generally speaking, electrolyte supplements offer a targeted approach to replace electrolytes, while sports drinks provide a broader solution with additional carbohydrates to further improve exercise and athletic performance.

How can I prevent electrolyte deficiencies?

The best way to prevent electrolyte deficiencies is to stay hydrated. You can do this by drinking adequate water throughout the day and eating a balanced diet rich in fruits and vegetables. 

Consider supplementing with electrolyte supplements if you engage in prolonged physical activity or experience excessive sweating due to hot and humid environments.

What are the symptoms of electrolyte deficiencies?

Common symptoms of electrolyte deficiencies include fatigue, cramps, dizziness, and headache. If left untreated, electrolyte deficiencies can lead to more serious health issues such as irregular heartbeat or seizures.

What are some tips for taking electrolyte supplements?

Always follow the directions on the product label and speak to your doctor before taking electrolyte supplements if you have any questions or underlying health concerns. 

If the flavor is too salty, adding extra water can dilute the supplement slightly.

Choose a reputable brand with accurate labeling, and be mindful of potential drug interactions when supplementing with multiple products. 

Finally, monitor your hydration status closely while taking electrolyte supplements and adjust dosages or discontinue use if necessary.

Conclusion

To wrap it up, finding the right alternative to Beachbody Hydrate is not just about the ethical concerns surrounding MLM products but also about considering the supplement's effectiveness. 

After evaluating Beachbody Hydrate, it's clear that its electrolyte content falls short of recommended daily intake. This raises doubts about its value and effectiveness.

Therefore, exploring electrolyte supplements such as Liquid I.V., LMNT, or DripDrop is a smart move to improve your hydration and exercise performance too. 

Ultimately, reading the label and considering all the benefits and risks before deciding is essential. This will ensure you get the most out of your electrolyte supplement and stay safe and hydrated!

Brittany Morgon

Brittany Morgon is an evidence-based nutrition and fitness coach, dog-mom, food science nerd, and pizza connoisseur helping people to break free from MLM schemes and achieve their sustainable weight loss goals.

Click here to learn more.

Previous
Previous

Food for Thought: Unraveling the Complex Relationship Between Food and Emotions

Next
Next

How to Read a Food Label